What makes a good read?

I’m not a great one for writing reviews, not just books, anything. It is the star system I particularly loath. I can understand its purpose, just not how it can be fairly applied. Without guidelines, it becomes a subjective box tick, almost a polarised like or dislike with a vague differentiation in the middle.
Ask me any day of the week for my top ten list of books, films or music, it is likely to vary each time according to my mood or memories. I don’t have favourites – no special colours, recipes or preferences for food. It is not that I lack consistency, it is more that I like variety.
When it comes to books my pleasure is fulfilled on many levels, but my top criteria is – does it hold my attention? Do I read it quickly – not hastily or speed reading – more a case of ‘do not disturb’. It could be because the plot is a real page turner, or may be I’ve become besotted with a character or it could be the prose, the writing style mesmerises me. The better the book, the sadder I feel at the end. When I finished Vikram Seth’s A Suitable Boy I went into mourning. Even after thousands of pages, I didn’t want it to end and went into some kind of mini-depression until I found a replacement.
My friends like to peruse my mini-library – I have good old-fashioned paper books, several hundred – and they come to borrow when the need arises. “What do you recommend?” I almost randomly pick something up and remark, “This was a good read, because…” the ending can vary according to my friends tastes – good historical setting, it made me laugh, it was a real whodunnit….. They trust me and generally the book comes back a few days later, well thumbed and I’m asked again.
It leads me to wonder about writing reviews here on my blog and I decided that Thursday’s would be my ‘That was a good read because’ day. Simply put I will say why I kept turning the pages and what held my attention, caught me and kept me ensnared. And if it was really good, I might tell you I mourned its passing, but I won’t be giving a rating.

2 thoughts on “What makes a good read?

  1. I don’t like the current rating system that sites have. The reason is that I’ve found that the system is too arbitrary. I can’t tell you how many times I’ve gotten a book only to be disappointed. A perfect example is Shades of Gray which I did not like. While others felt it so sexy, I found it to be stupid and so unbelieveable that I now try hard to look at several different sites, author’s blogs who write in the same genre, or see what my favorite authors have written before purchasing a book. So, I look forward to seeing what you have enjoyed and hopefully add some new authors to my library.

    • I found recommendations are the best kind of reviews, but even so, everyone has their own tastes and preferences and differing takes on the same book. I shall endeavor to make good choices for you.

Leave a Comment

%d bloggers like this: